CATTLEFACTS: "Makes More Money When You Sell Cattle"  US Cattle Cycle Key to Rising Prices
Cattlefacts "Cattlefacts Levels Your Playing Field"
 

By: Brian Herne
(Cattlefacts CEO)
May 1998.
bherne@cattlefacts.com.au

Cattle prices in Australia have shown modest improvement since late 1997 and Cattlefacts projects them to continue rising generally through to the year 2000-01, cattle producers will tend to make money (profits) in these years. Then, from around year 2002-03 Cattlefacts expects cattle prices should flatten and begin a dive for the next 3-4 years. Producers will tend to loose money in those years."

The key to understanding how projections like this are made (3-5 years ahead of time) and how you can make them and adjust your management to benefit from them, lies in an understanding of the U.S.A. 'cattle cycle' and its underlying influence on Australian cattle prices. The following is an overview of the cattle cycle and its effect on Australian cattle price levels.

Putting the Australian cattle industry in context:

The scope of cattle prices in Australia are primarily driven by beef prices in the USA for the following reasons.

  1. Total production from the huge 100+ million head U.S. herd is virtually all for domestic consumption. So their domestic market sets the price of their beef and cattle. (they import as much as they export).

  2. Sixty percent of Australian beef production relies on exports to both U.S.A. and Asia.

  3. Our beef competes with U.S. beef in both the USA and the Japanese markets. The sheer size of the U.S. beef market (about ten times larger than ours) ensures their market remains the price setter.

  4. U.S. domestic beef prices set the price boundaries for Australia export beef and hence our cattle prices.

Once you appreciate the primary dependence of Australian cattle prices on U.S. beef prices and that U.S. beef prices move with the cattle cycle, the cause of cyclical Australian cattle prices becomes clearer, and manageable.

The 'U.S. cattle cycle:

A very good analogy for the cattle cycle is a year but instead of having 12 months and four seasons, it lasts 9-11 years and has three seasons -expansion, consolidation and liquidation. Just as you would have difficulty fattening cattle in your off season, its is difficult or unlikely you will make profits in the liquidation season of the cattle cycle. But, when the cycle turns to expansion, making profits is relatively easy.

The Cattle cycle is an ocellation in cattle numbers between too many cattle and not enough cattle for the needs of the US domestic market. Because cattle prices are 90% supply driven, this results in the typical situations of  'high supply and low prices' and 'light supply with high price'. However the significant understanding is that the complete cycle takes  9-11 years to play out and has repeated itself over the past 70 years.

What causes the oscillation in cattle numbers and beef production and hence cattle prices is essentially a producer response to cattle prices themselves. What ensures the cycle repeats itself is the time gap between joining a cow and selling its calf and also the time lag of consumer response to beef price levels.

The US Cattle Cycle  

NOTE: This graph is from late 1997 and projects the cycle reaching bottom in 2000-01. Current estimates suggest it will bottom in 1999. Hence, Australian Cattlefacts is projecting best profit years between 1998-2001. Back in 1996, Cattlefacts projected that this current cycle was likely to be interrupted and be a precursor to shorter more volatile cycles in the coming years. There is current speculation this could occur.
(Note: Graph is of cattle numbers- not prices.)

The Cattle cycle upside:

On the upside of the cycle (where its headed for right now) lower cattle numbers produce less beef than demand so cattle prices tend to rise. A rise in cattle prices encourages producers to retain more heifers and keep cows a year or two more. This reduces the supply of slaughter cattle even further; prices continue to rise and producers tend retain more breeders -etc. Eventually these retained breeders produce high supply which busts the market. From the bottom of the cattle cycle the expansion phase typically lasts 6-7 years with peak cattle prices years near the middle.Because.

Australian cattle prices tend to lift in sympathy with the U.S. cattle cycle, these are the years of greatest profit potential for Australian producers. However, the more Australian production tend towards high supply in these years, often caused by drought, the less of the cash benefits producers' get and the more processors keep.

The cattle cycle downside:

Eventually the production from increasing cattle numbers more than satisfies demand. Buyers become less competitive and cattle prices flatten. The downside spiral begins when the more prices fall, the deeper producers cut into breeder numbers to maintain cash flow. Initially this causes an even greater increase in beef supply than cattle numbers would suggest and tends to hammer prices down. From the top of cattle cycle, the liquidation phase usually lasts 3-4 years.

In these years, and sometimes an additional year either side, cattle and beef prices fall to unprofitable levels. The cattle cycle and its effects do not discriminate between 'good' cattlemen with 'excellent' cattle and the other type. In these years even 'good' producers tend to loose money. Others are squeezed out.

For Australian producers, many other factors sit on top of the underlying influence of the cattle cycle. Drought, exchange rates, health issues and the economies of our trading partners are a few of the topically evident ones. However, these issues affect the price of cattle only within the margin available from the underlying U.S. cattle cycle. Herd liquidation inevitably produces low prices. Expansion brings the opportunity of high prices.

The U.S. cattle cycle is so important to the cyclical fortunes of Australian cattle producers that Cattlefacts has claimed "Australian producers should understand the U.S. cattle cycle FIRST if they want to make money from cattle. Production and marketing strategies will then have a basis in reality.

(Note: Full version available to members in 'Members-only newsletter' on site)

© Cattlefacts May 1998-2000 -  Cattlefacts.com.au